Old Nintendo Games: What Your Retro Games Are Worth 2026
By the Numbers
Store ratings checked Nov 3, 2026. How we count
Most sell for under $50 loose, and a few sell for hundreds or thousands. In 7,160 eBay sales of 103 US Nintendo games from Jul 6 to Oct 3, 2026, Super Mario Bros./Duck Hunt sold for a median of $7 loose and Super Mario World $17. Loose Little Samson cartridges sold for $2,650, Aero Fighters $1,775 and ClayFighter: Sculptor’s Cut $1,362. A complete EarthBound, box and all, sold for $2,999, against $400 for the cartridge alone.
What people checked in Underpriced
| Underpriced data, Jul–Sep 2026 | Figure | n |
|---|---|---|
| Nintendo games and consoles checks | 37 from 26 people | 37 |
| Median price people were asked | $8.66 | 11 |
| Median value from matching sold listings | $38 (middle half $30 to $48) | 6 |
| Rated worth buying at that price | 36% | 11 |
| Median projected profit after fees and shipping (Apr–Sep 2026) | $3.17 | 10 |
Nintendo games and consoles checked in Underpriced had a median tag of $8.66, and the six that matched recent sales were worth about $38. Projected profit after fees and shipping came to only $3.17 over the longer April to September stretch, and about a third were rated worth buying at their price. Buying every old game you see doesn’t pay; knowing the titles in the tables below does. How we count.
Where these prices come from
eBay sold listings, Jul 6 to Oct 3, 2026, n=7,160. One search per game, US releases only, item price before shipping. “Loose” is the cartridge alone; “complete in box” has the box and manual. For GameCube, “without manual” is the disc with or without its case, and “complete” has the case and manual. Each search returns the most recent sales first, so common games cover the last few weeks and rare ones the whole stretch. Best-offer sales are left out, because eBay doesn’t show the accepted price, and so are Japanese and PAL copies, sealed, new and graded copies, lots, and listings that mention reproductions. Unmarked reproductions still turn up, so within each column we left out sales under a quarter of the game’s median, and sales over four times it, which are usually boxed copies listed as loose. A dot means fewer than 5 sales. How we count.
Loose, complete in box and sealed
Loose. Just the cartridge. That’s how most old games turn up, and it’s the cheapest way to own any title.
Complete in box (CIB). The box, the manual and the cartridge, plus any inserts the game shipped with. Boxes were usually thrown away, so a complete copy is worth several times a loose one. Super Metroid sold for $90 loose and $386 complete, Chrono Trigger for $270 and $791, and Mike Tyson’s Punch-Out!! for $40 and $186. Box condition matters: crushed corners, writing, tears and sun fading all cost money, and so does a missing map or insert.
Sealed and graded. Factory sealed copies, often graded in a plastic case by companies like Wata, VGA or CGC, are a separate market. Prices spiked in 2021, when a sealed, graded copy of Super Mario Bros. sold for $2 million, and have cooled since. Sealed copies are also faked and resealed, so leave them to specialists unless you know the market well.
NES games
| Game | Loose, median (sales) | Complete in box, median (sales) |
|---|---|---|
| Little Samson | $2,650 (6) | · |
| The Flintstones: The Surprise at Dinosaur Peak | $1,400 (9) | · |
| Bonk’s Adventure | $900 (5) | · |
| Zombie Nation | $500 (8) | · |
| Chip 'n Dale Rescue Rangers 2 | $399 (11) | · |
| Snow Bros. | $316 (9) | · |
| DuckTales 2 | $281 (29) | · |
| Mega Man 5 | $155 (52) | $560 (6) |
| Darkwing Duck | $74 (62) | · |
| Mega Man 6 | $55 (73) | $257 (11) |
| Mega Man 4 | $43 (97) | $175 (7) |
| Mike Tyson’s Punch-Out!! | $40 (137) | $186 (9) |
| Wario’s Woods | $35 (18) | $100 (5) |
| Contra | $35 (90) | · |
| The Legend of Zelda | $32 (72) | $230 (14) |
| Kirby’s Adventure | $32 (89) | $98 (14) |
| Crystalis | $26 (81) | $80 (14) |
| Super Mario Bros. 3 | $18 (97) | $95 (13) |
| Tetris | $10 (62) | $23 (15) |
| Super Mario Bros./Duck Hunt | $7 (64) | · |
Little Samson came out from Taito in late 1992, when the NES was winding down in the US, and few copies were made. Loose copies sold for $2,650, and no complete copy sold in the window.
The Flintstones: The Surprise at Dinosaur Peak was one of the last NES games, released in 1994 in very small numbers. Loose copies sold for $1,400.
Late Capcom games sell for far more than you’d guess. DuckTales 2 sold for $281 loose and Chip 'n Dale Rescue Rangers 2 for $399. Mega Man 5 sold for $155 loose, nearly three times Mega Man 6 at $55.
Famous games are cheap loose. Super Mario Bros. 3 sold for $18, Tetris $10 and Super Mario Bros./Duck Hunt $7. Boxed copies are where these pay: a complete Legend of Zelda sold for $230.
Some of the rarest NES cartridges, like Stadium Events and the Nintendo World Championships competition carts, almost never come up for sale. Panic Restaurant, Power Blade 2 and Cowboy Kid sold fewer than 5 times each in the window, too few to price here.
SNES games
| Game | Loose, median (sales) | Complete in box, median (sales) |
|---|---|---|
| Aero Fighters | $1,775 (5) | · |
| Hagane: The Final Conflict | $1,500 (7) | · |
| Pocky & Rocky 2 | $594 (8) | · |
| Metal Warriors | $500 (14) | · |
| EarthBound | $400 (82) | $2,999 (5) |
| Harvest Moon | $388 (12) | · |
| Mega Man X3 | $350 (30) | · |
| Wild Guns | $340 (13) | · |
| Chrono Trigger | $270 (77) | $791 (12) |
| Super Turrican 2 | $265 (11) | · |
| Ogre Battle: The March of the Black Queen | $200 (23) | · |
| Demon’s Crest | $185 (33) | · |
| Lufia II: Rise of the Sinistrals | $175 (37) | · |
| Super Metroid | $90 (112) | $386 (19) |
| Final Fantasy III | $85 (118) | $233 (10) |
| Secret of Mana | $60 (103) | $171 (13) |
| The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past | $40 (122) | $250 (9) |
| Mega Man X | $35 (87) | $203 (6) |
| Super Mario Kart | $30 (111) | $97 (8) |
| Donkey Kong Country | $19 (60) | · |
| Super Mario World | $17 (91) | · |
EarthBound sold poorly in the US in 1995, despite a big ad campaign, and later became one of the most wanted SNES games. It came in an oversized box with a player’s guide, which is why complete copies sold for $2,999 and loose cartridges for $400. It is also one of the most reproduced SNES games, so check the board before you pay.
Hagane: The Final Conflict was a rental exclusive at Blockbuster in North America, so few copies ever reached collectors. Loose cartridges went for $1,500.
Aero Fighters, Pocky & Rocky 2, Metal Warriors and Wild Guns are late releases with small print runs. Aero Fighters sold for $1,775 loose, Pocky & Rocky 2 $594 and Metal Warriors $500.
RPGs hold value. Chrono Trigger sold for $270 loose, Harvest Moon $388, Ogre Battle $200 and Lufia II $175. Mega Man X3 sold for $350, ten times the first Mega Man X at $35.
The best sellers are the cheapest. Super Mario World sold for $17 loose and Donkey Kong Country $19.
N64 games
| Game | Loose, median (sales) | Complete in box, median (sales) |
|---|---|---|
| ClayFighter: Sculptor’s Cut | $1,362 (14) | · |
| Bomberman 64: The Second Attack | $350 (23) | · |
| Castlevania: Legacy of Darkness | $175 (25) | · |
| Ogre Battle 64 | $165 (53) | $350 (10) |
| Conker’s Bad Fur Day | $159 (98) | $370 (17) |
| Indiana Jones and the Infernal Machine | $120 (33) | · |
| The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask | $100 (90) | $248 (16) |
| Snowboard Kids 2 | $100 (39) | · |
| Paper Mario | $80 (108) | $234 (10) |
| Harvest Moon 64 | $72 (44) | $250 (5) |
| The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time | $49 (85) | $200 (5) |
| Mario Party 3 | $49 (34) | · |
| Super Smash Bros. | $48 (102) | $200 (6) |
| Mario Kart 64 | $40 (96) | $106 (8) |
| Super Mario 64 | $40 (82) | $105 (5) |
| Mario Party 2 | $40 (55) | · |
| Mario Party | $35 (43) | · |
| Donkey Kong 64 | $30 (67) | $110 (6) |
| GoldenEye 007 | $28 (117) | $80 (9) |
| Pokemon Snap | $20 (120) | $94 (6) |
ClayFighter: Sculptor’s Cut was a Blockbuster rental exclusive, so most copies have rental stickers or marks. Loose cartridges sold for $1,362. A clean copy with no sign of rental use deserves a closer look before you buy it.
Bomberman 64: The Second Attack came out in 2000 in small numbers and sold for $350 loose.
Late and niche games sell well: Conker’s Bad Fur Day, a mature Rare game from 2001, sold for $159 loose and $370 complete; Castlevania: Legacy of Darkness $175; Ogre Battle 64 $165; Indiana Jones and the Infernal Machine $120.
The famous games are $30 to $50 loose. Super Mario 64 and Mario Kart 64 sold for $40, Ocarina of Time $49 and GoldenEye 007 $28. Majora’s Mask is the exception at $100.
GameCube games
| Game | Without manual, median (sales) | Complete, median (sales) |
|---|---|---|
| Cubivore: Survival of the Fittest | · | $750 (13) |
| Gotcha Force | $258 (14) | $500 (13) |
| Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance | $150 (33) | $210 (63) |
| Chibi-Robo! | $150 (18) | $204 (37) |
| Pokemon XD: Gale of Darkness | $152 (27) | $200 (31) |
| Ribbit King | $110 (6) | $185 (15) |
| Skies of Arcadia Legends | $130 (29) | $170 (64) |
| Pokemon Colosseum | $116 (31) | $168 (43) |
| Eternal Darkness: Sanity’s Requiem | $78 (34) | $115 (90) |
| The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker | $60 (33) | $75 (70) |
| Mario Kart: Double Dash!! | $55 (45) | $70 (59) |
| Ikaruga | $40 (10) | $68 (33) |
| Super Smash Bros. Melee | $50 (37) | $65 (58) |
| Pikmin 2 | $40 (27) | $63 (73) |
| Baten Kaitos Origins | $47 (9) | $62 (28) |
| Luigi’s Mansion | $45 (31) | $60 (50) |
| Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door | $29 (18) | $47 (51) |
| Super Mario Sunshine | $35 (33) | $46 (66) |
| Tales of Symphonia | $20 (22) | $30 (80) |
| Metroid Prime | $15 (5) | $25 (51) |
Cubivore, Gotcha Force and Ribbit King came out in small numbers in North America. Complete copies of Cubivore sold for $750, Gotcha Force $500 and Ribbit King $185.
Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance, Chibi-Robo! and the two Pokemon games sell for $150 or more complete. Path of Radiance sold for $210, Chibi-Robo! $204, Pokemon XD: Gale of Darkness $200 and Pokemon Colosseum $168.
Some well-known games are cheap. Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door, remade for Switch in 2024, sold for $47 complete, and Metroid Prime for $25.
For GameCube, the manual matters less than the box does for cartridges: Melee sold for $50 without a manual and $65 complete.
Game Boy Advance games
| Game | Loose, median (sales) | Complete in box, median (sales) |
|---|---|---|
| Pokemon Emerald | $215 (80) | $510 (6) |
| Pokemon LeafGreen | $104 (76) | · |
| Pokemon FireRed | $102 (93) | · |
| The Legend of Zelda: The Minish Cap | $93 (82) | $255 (10) |
| Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow | $92 (68) | $225 (13) |
| Pokemon Ruby | $90 (65) | · |
| Pokemon Sapphire | $80 (27) | · |
| Metroid: Zero Mission | $67 (91) | $199 (12) |
| Fire Emblem | $58 (62) | · |
| Fire Emblem: The Sacred Stones | $55 (99) | $150 (16) |
| Metroid Fusion | $50 (114) | $152 (12) |
| Golden Sun: The Lost Age | $39 (115) | $120 (13) |
| Golden Sun | $31 (65) | · |
| Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Red Rescue Team | $28 (154) | $173 (7) |
Pokemon games lead. Loose Emerald sold for $215, LeafGreen $104, FireRed $102, Ruby $90 and Sapphire $80, and a complete Emerald for $510. They are also the most reproduced games on the system: half of all loose Emerald sales landed between $182 and $245, so one for much under $150 is very likely a reproduction.
Outside Pokemon, The Minish Cap ($93 loose, $255 complete) and Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow ($92 and $225) sell best, with both Metroid games close behind.
Game Boy and Game Boy Color games
| Game | Loose, median (sales) | Complete in box, median (sales) |
|---|---|---|
| Mega Man V | $220 (7) | · |
| Pokemon Crystal | $165 (79) | · |
| Kid Dracula | $145 (12) | · |
| Pokemon Yellow | $64 (82) | · |
| Pokemon Gold | $60 (95) | $230 (7) |
| Pokemon Silver | $55 (105) | $325 (9) |
| Pokemon Red | $53 (65) | · |
| Pokemon Blue | $52 (114) | $400 (7) |
Pokemon Crystal sold for $165 loose, roughly three times Red ($53), Blue ($52), Yellow ($64), Gold ($60) and Silver ($55). Complete copies are where the original Pokemon games pay: Blue sold for $400 complete, Silver $325 and Gold $230.
Two non-Pokemon cartridges worth knowing are Mega Man V at $220 loose and Kid Dracula at $145. The Pokemon games are heavily reproduced here too, so check the label and the board before you pay.
How to spot fake Nintendo games
Reproductions are common for the expensive games in these tables, especially Pokemon on Game Boy and Game Boy Advance, EarthBound and the rare NES and SNES titles.
Start with the price. A game selling far below the tables above is the most common sign of a fake.
Check the label. Real labels are sharp, with correct colors and fonts. Blurry printing, washed-out colors and spelling mistakes are bad signs. Compare against photos of a known authentic copy.
Check the shell. The plastic should match the original in color and texture, with clean, even seams.
Open it. For an expensive game, open the cartridge and compare the board to photos of a genuine one. Real boards have Nintendo markings, and the chips carry date codes, usually a year and a week like 9423. A chip dated after the game came out means a fake or a repaired board.
Check the save. Pokemon Ruby, Sapphire and Emerald use a battery to run the in-game clock, so a missing battery is a red flag. FireRed and LeafGreen don’t use one. Saving and reloading a game is a quick test for any battery-backed cartridge.
Where to find old Nintendo games
Thrift stores. Games turn up in bins or behind the counter, often all at the same price. Visit often, since good games go quickly.
Estate and garage sales. These are the best places to find a whole collection at once, sometimes with boxes and manuals kept together. Our estate sale buying guide covers how to work them.
Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist. People sell boxes of games as one lot, priced by the box. Sort out the valuable titles, and sell the rest as a lot or to a game store.
Local game stores. They price at market, so the deals are rare, but they’re a quick place to sell common games and a good way to learn what local buyers pay.
Storage unit auctions. Occasionally a unit holds a game collection. See our storage unit auction guide.
For more on building a sourcing route, see our thrift store flipping guide.
How to price your game
- Find the exact title and region. US cartridges are what these tables cover; Japanese and PAL versions sell differently.
- Decide loose or complete and check the condition of the label, box and manual.
- Start from the tables above to see the range you’re in.
- Search sold listings for the same game and condition. Our eBay sold listings search builds the search in one click, and our eBay sold listings guide explains how to compare. PriceCharting tracks loose and complete prices over time; see our PriceCharting alternatives for other sources.
- Work out what you keep with the flip profit calculator.
A photo of the game in Underpriced identifies it and checks recent sold prices in one step.
Where to sell old Nintendo games
eBay reaches the most collectors, and every sale in our sample happened there. It costs 13.6% of the total sale plus $0.40 per order in most categories, including video games, with payment processing included. eBay fees verified Oct 1, 2026 (eBay Help). For anything valuable, photograph the label, the back, the board if you’ve opened it, and every side of the box. Our guide to selling collectibles online covers listing in more detail.
Facebook Marketplace suits lots and mid-priced games sold locally, with no fee on local pickup. Meet somewhere public.
Mercari takes 10% of the item price and shipping, and suits mid-priced games.
Whatnot sells through live auctions. New sellers start on the Standard tier, 8% of the sale plus 2.9% + $0.30 payment processing, and it works best once you have an audience.
Game stores and online buyers pay well under what a game sells for, but take a whole collection at once. That can make sense for a big box of common games.
For a side-by-side look at fees, use our eBay, Mercari and Poshmark fee calculator.
Packing and shipping
Loose cartridges. Put the cartridge in a sleeve or small bag to protect the label, then in a padded mailer. For valuable ones, use a small box with bubble wrap.
Complete in box. Wrap the box in bubble wrap and pack it in a larger box with at least 2 inches of padding on every side, so it can’t shift and dent the corners. For expensive games, double-box.
Graded games. Wrap the case and pack it so it can’t move. A hard knock can crack it.
For loose cartridges under 1 lb, USPS Ground Advantage commercial pricing runs $6.93 to $8.40 depending on zone. USPS prices from Notice 123, effective July 12, 2026. Insure anything valuable. Our shipping guide for resellers compares the options.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are my old Nintendo games worth anything?
Probably some of them. In eBay sales from Jul 6 to Oct 3, 2026, famous games like Super Mario World ($17) and Super Mario Bros. 3 ($18) sold for little loose, while late and rare releases like Little Samson ($2,650) and Aero Fighters ($1,775) sold for far more. Look up each title on its own before you sell a box of games as one lot.
Is complete in box worth more than loose?
Yes, often several times more. Super Metroid sold for $90 loose and $386 complete in the same sample, and Chrono Trigger for $270 and $791. A missing manual or insert, or a damaged box, brings the price down.
How do I tell if a Pokemon game is fake?
Start with the price: a loose Pokemon Emerald sold for $215 in our sample, so one at a fraction of that is almost certainly fake. Check the label print, open the cartridge if you can, and look for Nintendo markings and date codes on the board. Ruby, Sapphire and Emerald should have a battery for the clock.
Should I get my Nintendo games graded?
Usually not. Grading costs money and takes time, and it mostly pays on sealed copies of valuable games. For loose cartridges and common complete games, the graded price rarely covers the cost.
Conclusion
Most old Nintendo games sell for under $50 loose, and the value is in a short list of late, rare or niche releases, plus complete copies with their boxes. Learn the titles in these tables, check every expensive game for signs of a reproduction, and price from recent sales of the same game in the same condition.
Related guides:
- Thrift Store Flipping: The Complete Guide
- Estate Sale Buying: Complete Guide 2026
- Storage Unit Auction Flipping Guide 2026
- How to Use eBay Sold Listings for Price Research
- How to Sell Collectibles Online: Complete Guide 2026
- eBay vs. Poshmark vs. Mercari Fee Calculator
- Cheapest Shipping Options for Resellers 2026
- PriceCharting Alternatives 2026
- Best Thrift Store Items to Flip on eBay 2026
Related articles
what is this worth guide for retro game finds
Search what any item sold for on eBay, free. Name it, match sold listings and use the typical price. Six real thrift finds valued end to end, fees included.
video game flipping complete guide
Reselling video games in 2026: learn which consoles, titles, conditions, and sourcing channels make game flips worth the risk.
PriceCharting alternatives for game-value research
Compare the best PriceCharting alternatives for 2026. Learn which tools work better for resellers outside video games and cards, and how to choose the right pricing workflow.
Goodwill finds that are worth money
Goodwill and thrift store finds guide with jackets, cookware, electronics, and buy-price math so you can spot the real flips faster.
Tools that help with this topic
eBay sold comps for retro games
Build source-backed sold-comp research links for eBay Advanced Search, eBay Product Research, Mercari, and Poshmark, plus a 7-comp pricing worksheet.
flip profit calculator for Nintendo finds
Calculate net profit, ROI, margin, break-even price, and target sale price after marketplace fees, shipping, reserves, and labor. Free calculator included.
listing title optimizer for game listings
Build factual marketplace titles with source-checked limits, emoji cleanup, missing-field warnings, and crosslisting variants across six platforms.