How to Price Items to Sell: The Complete Pricing Strategy Guide for Resellers 2026
Published: January 29, 2026
Author: The Underpriced Team
Reading Time: 11 min
Tags: pricing strategy, reseller tips, how to price, ebay pricing, secondhand pricing
There’s a pricing paradox every reseller faces: price too high and your item sits for months. Price too low and you’re leaving real money on the table.
Finding that sweet spot—the price that maximizes profit while ensuring a reasonable time to sale—is arguably the most important skill in reselling. Get it right, and you build a profitable flipping business. Get it wrong, and you’re stuck with a death pile of overpriced inventory or a PayPal account that doesn’t match your effort.
In 2026, with more competition and smarter buyers than ever, gut-feeling pricing isn’t good enough anymore. You need a data-driven strategy.
This guide breaks down exactly how to price items to sell—from research methods to psychological tactics to platform-specific adjustments. Whether you’re selling one item from your closet or running a full-time reselling operation, these strategies will help you price with confidence.
The Foundation: Research Before Pricing
Before you put a price tag on anything, you need to know what the market will actually pay. The biggest mistake resellers make? Pricing based on what they think something is worth rather than what buyers are actually paying.
Why Sold Listings Beat Asking Prices
This is Rule #1 of reseller pricing: never price based on asking prices. Only sold prices matter.
Here’s why:
- Asking prices = What sellers hope to get
- Sold prices = What buyers actually paid
That vintage Sony Walkman might have 50 listings asking $150. But if the last 20 that actually sold were $60-80, that’s the real market value. The rest are overpriced and sitting.
Sellers can ask for anything. The market decides what it’s willing to pay.
The eBay Sold Listings Method
eBay sold listings are the gold standard for pricing research in 2026. Here’s the exact process:
Step 1: Go to eBay.com and search for your item (be specific: brand + model + size + color + condition)
Step 2: Click “Advanced” next to the search bar, then check “Sold listings” under “Show only”
Step 3: Review the last 30-90 days of sales
Step 4: Note the price range, average, and median
Step 5: Adjust for your item’s specific condition and completeness
Use our eBay Sold Link Generator to skip the manual filtering—enter any keyword and get a filtered sold listings link instantly. It’s especially useful when sourcing on mobile.
Pro Tip: Filter to “Buy It Now” sales only. Auction prices are unpredictable—one item might get a bidding war and sell for double market value, while another ends at 3 AM with zero interest and sells for half. Buy It Now prices are more consistent and reliable for pricing research.
Other Research Sources
While eBay solds are your primary source, cross-reference with:
- Poshmark Sold Comps: Search the item, filter to “Sold” status. Especially useful for clothing and accessories.
- Mercari Sold History: Search and filter by “Sold” to see what’s actually moving.
- Google Shopping: Shows current retail/new prices for context.
- StockX/GOAT: For sneakers and streetwear, these show authenticated market prices.
The 5-Minute Research Rule: Spend 5 minutes researching any item before pricing. It sounds like a lot when you have 50 items to list, but mispricing costs you far more time in relisting, price drops, and lost sales.
The 3 Pricing Strategies
Once you have your comp research, you need to decide where in that price range to position your item. There are three main strategies:
Strategy 1: Market Price (Match Comps Exactly)
What it is: Price your item at the average or median of recent sold comps.
Best for:
- Items with consistent, predictable demand
- Common items with heavy competition
- When you want a balance of profit and turnover
- Items in average condition
Pros:
- Reasonable time to sale (typically 2-4 weeks)
- Fair profit margins
- Low risk of overpricing
- Good for most inventory
Cons:
- Not maximizing profit on premium items
- Competing with everyone else at the same price
Example: Your research shows Nike Air Max 90s in your size/colorway selling for $75, $80, $72, $85, $78 (average: $78). You list at $80.
Strategy 2: Competitive Pricing (5-15% Below Market)
What it is: Price slightly below the market average to be the most attractive option.
Best for:
- Items sitting in inventory too long
- High competition categories
- When you need cash flow quickly
- Common items where turnover beats margin
- Items with minor condition issues
Pros:
- Faster sales (often 50-70% faster than market price)
- Better cash flow
- Less time managing listings
- First sale when buyers comparison shop
Cons:
- Lower per-item profit
- Training buyers to expect discounts
The Faster Turnover Math:
Let’s say you can sell an item for $100 (market price) in 30 days, or for $90 (10% below) in 10 days.
Option A: $100 sale in 30 days = $100/month velocity
Option B: $90 sale in 10 days = $270/month velocity (you can flip that capital 3x faster)
If you reinvest your capital, competitive pricing often generates more total profit over time than holding out for maximum per-item margins.
Pro Tip: This strategy works best when your cost basis is low. If you bought something for $5 at a thrift store, selling for $45 vs $50 has minimal impact on your ROI—but it might mean the difference between selling in 3 days vs 3 weeks.
Strategy 3: Premium Pricing (10-20% Above Market)
What it is: Price above the average for items that justify it.
Best for:
- Rare or unique items (limited editions, vintage, discontinued)
- Exceptional condition (new with tags, sealed, mint)
- Complete sets when most are missing pieces
- Items with provenance or special history
- Desirable sizes in high-demand categories
Pros:
- Maximum profit per item
- Attracts serious collectors willing to pay
- Positions your store as quality-focused
Cons:
- Longer time to sale
- Risk of overpricing and never selling
- Requires truly premium items
When it works: You find a vintage Nike windbreaker from a sold-out collaboration. Normal vintage Nike jackets sell for $50-70. But this specific colorway hasn’t appeared on eBay in 6 months, and when it does, it sells immediately. You price at $95-110 and wait for the right buyer.
When it doesn’t work: You have a common Tommy Hilfiger polo and price it 20% above market because “yours is in great condition.” Everyone’s Tommy polo is in great condition. You’ll sit on it forever.
Platform-Specific Pricing Adjustments
The same item can command different prices on different platforms. Smart resellers adjust their pricing strategy based on where they’re selling.
eBay
Audience: Widest, most diverse buyer pool. Collectors, bargain hunters, and everyone in between.
Pricing approach: Market price. eBay’s massive audience means the market efficiently prices most items. Price at comps.
Key factor: eBay buyers heavily comparison shop and can see sold data themselves. Overpricing gets ignored quickly.
Poshmark
Audience: Fashion-focused, often expects to negotiate, values presentation.
Pricing approach: Price 30-40%+ above your target price. Poshmark has an “offer culture”—buyers routinely send offers 30-50% below asking. If you want $50, list at $70-75.
Key factor: Free shipping via Posh label is included, so factor that into your pricing. Bundle discounts are expected. Use “Closet Clear Out” sales strategically.
Mercari
Audience: Price-conscious, casual buyers looking for deals.
Pricing approach: Competitive pricing. Mercari buyers are bargain-hunting and will choose the lowest price for comparable items. Price at or slightly below market.
Key factor: Mercari promotes “smart pricing” (auto price drops), which can help move stale inventory but also signals desperation. Use judiciously.
Facebook Marketplace
Audience: Local buyers who want to inspect items, no-shipping shoppers.
Pricing approach: Often 10-15% higher than eBay. Why? No shipping for buyer (instant gratification), no platform fees for local pickup, and less competition (local area only).
Key factor: Built-in negotiation culture. Everyone asks “what’s your lowest?” Build in 10-15% negotiation room. If you want $80, list at $90-95.
Depop
Audience: Gen Z, trend-focused, values aesthetic and vintage/Y2K styles.
Pricing approach: Premium pricing works here for the right items. Vintage 90s/Y2K pieces, vintage band tees, and aesthetic streetwear command premiums that wouldn’t fly on eBay or Mercari.
Key factor: Photos and styling matter enormously. A well-photographed item can sell for 20-30% more than the same item with basic photos.
Need to compare fees? Use our Platform Fee Calculator to see exactly what you’ll net on each platform before deciding where to list.
The Psychology of Pricing
How you display your price matters almost as much as the price itself. These psychological tactics have been proven across retail and reselling:
The Power of .99 Endings
$49.99 feels significantly cheaper than $50.00—even though it’s a penny difference. This “left-digit effect” is well-documented in pricing research. Your brain processes “4” before “9.99” and anchors on it.
When to use: For items under $100 where perceived value matters. $29.99, $49.99, $79.99 all feel more affordable.
When to skip: Very premium items. $1,499 feels cheaper, but $1,500 feels more “round” and premium.
Round Numbers for Quality Perception
Counter-intuitively, round numbers ($50, $100, $200) signal confidence and quality. They feel deliberate, like you know exactly what your item is worth.
When to use: Rare items, collectibles, premium brands where you want to project quality.
Example: A vintage Rolex watch at $1,997 feels like the seller is trying to trick you. $2,000 feels confident and premium.
The Anchor Effect
If you list an item for $100 and drop it to $80, buyers feel like they’re getting a deal—even if $80 was fair market value all along.
Some sellers start high intentionally to give themselves room for “sales” that bring items to true market price while making buyers feel like winners.
Use carefully: This works, but it can also train your audience to never buy at full price.
Bundle Psychology
People love deals, and bundles feel like deals—even when the math doesn’t actually favor the buyer.
“$25 each or 2 for $45” sounds like a deal. Most buyers don’t calculate that it’s only a $5 savings. They just hear “deal” and buy two.
Reseller tip: Create bundles of complementary items or similar sizes. Move slow inventory by bundling it with popular items.
Pricing by Category
Different categories have different pricing dynamics. Here’s what to watch for:
Clothing
The #1 factor: Condition. A $60 dress with stains or holes might be worth $15 or nothing. Check armpit areas, collars, cuffs, and knees carefully.
Sizing matters: “Goldilocks sizes” (M/L for women, M/L/XL for men) sell faster and sometimes for more. XXS and 3XL can take months to move.
Brand premiums: Same condition, same style—Lululemon beats Target activewear by 5-10x. Know your brands.
Electronics
Model year is everything: A 2024 MacBook Pro and a 2019 model look similar in photos but have massively different values. Always specify the exact model and year.
“Tested and working” premium: Electronics that clearly state “tested, fully functional, factory reset” command 10-20% more than vague “powers on” listings.
Missing accessories: Calculate what replacements cost. A laptop without charger loses $30-50 in value; price accordingly.
Collectibles
Graded vs. ungraded: A PSA 10 Pokémon card might sell for 10x the raw version. Grading has costs and risks—decide if it’s worth it based on raw value first.
Completeness: A video game with box, manual, and inserts is worth 2-3x a loose cartridge. Document everything included.
Condition descriptions matter: “Light shelf wear” vs. “like new” vs. “sealed”—each tier has distinct price points.
Furniture
Local market conditions: Unlike shipped items, furniture prices vary heavily by city. A mid-century dresser in Austin might fetch $800; the same piece in rural Iowa might max out at $300.
Seasonal awareness: Patio furniture peaks in spring/early summer. Indoor furniture (desks, tables) peaks in back-to-school and pre-holiday.
Transport factors: Anything requiring a truck to move has limited buyers. Price to sell, not to sit.
When to Drop Prices
Overpriced inventory is dead capital. Here’s how to know when to cut prices—and by how much.
The 7-14-30 Day Rule
7 days: No views, no watchers? Your title or photos might be the problem, not the price. Revise your listing first.
14 days: Good views but no sales or offers? You’re likely 10-15% overpriced. Make your first price drop.
30 days: Still sitting? Drop another 10-15%. If you’ve dropped twice and it’s still not moving, you may have misjudged the market or have condition issues.
How Much to Drop
10-15% per drop is the sweet spot. Big enough to matter, small enough to not obliterate your margin.
Avoid tiny 2-3% drops—they’re invisible to buyers and waste your time.
Avoid massive 40%+ drops unless you’re desperate to clear inventory. You might regret it when a $40 item that wouldn’t sell at $60 would have sold at $50.
When to Relist vs. Reduce
Relist (delete and recreate):
- Photos need improvement
- Title was poor and buried the listing
- You want the “fresh listing” algorithm boost
- Item has been up 60+ days
Reduce price:
- Listing is solid, just overpriced
- You want to notify watchers of the drop
- Item is getting views, just no bites
Use the Break-Even Calculator to know your floor—never drop below your break-even point unless you’re intentionally taking a loss to clear inventory.
When NOT to Drop Prices
Not every slow-selling item needs a price cut. Sometimes patience pays.
Rare and Unique Items
A limited-edition sneaker or vintage piece with no recent comps might simply be waiting for the right buyer. If you’ve confirmed the value through past sales (even if months ago), hold firm.
Seasonal Items Approaching Season
That vintage ski jacket sitting all summer? Don’t drop it in September—October through February is when it sells. Holiday decorations sell November-December. Patio furniture sells March-June.
Items with Steady Interest
Check your stats. If an item has consistent views and multiple watchers but hasn’t sold, the price might be fine—it’s just waiting for the right buyer to pull the trigger. This is different from an item with zero engagement.
Rule of Thumb: If an item is getting zero views, it’s a visibility problem (title, photos, category). If it’s getting views but no sales, it’s likely price.
Common Pricing Mistakes
Avoid these errors that cost resellers thousands every year:
1. Underselling Out of Impatience
You list an item for $80. After 2 weeks, you panic and drop to $50. It sells the next day.
The buyer would have paid $70. You left $20 on the table because you couldn’t wait another week.
Fix: Follow the 7-14-30 day rule. Make systematic, moderate drops rather than panic slashes.
2. Ignoring Fees and Shipping in Calculations
“I bought it for $15 and sold it for $50—$35 profit!”
No. After eBay’s ~13% fee ($6.50), shipping you paid ($8), and packaging ($2), your profit is $18.50. Still good, but very different.
Fix: Always calculate net profit, not gross. Use our ROI Calculator before buying anything.
3. Copying Asking Prices Instead of Sold Prices
You search eBay, see similar items listed at $100, and price yours at $95 thinking you’re competitive.
But those $100 listings have been sitting for 4 months. The items that actually sold went for $60-70.
Fix: Always filter to “Sold Items.” Asking prices are fiction; sold prices are fact.
4. Emotional Attachment Pricing
“I paid $200 for this originally, so I want at least $100 back.”
The market doesn’t care what you paid. If comps show $60, that’s what it’s worth—regardless of your emotional investment.
Fix: Price based on market data, not personal history with the item.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I price something with no sold comps?
If you can’t find exact comps, search for:
- Same brand, similar item
- Same item type, similar brands
- Related categories or styles
If nothing helps, price conservatively (market rate for similar-but-not-exact items) and be prepared to adjust based on interest.
Should I always offer free shipping or separate it?
It depends on the platform:
- eBay: Free shipping converts better but hide shipping in your price
- Poshmark: Shipping is standardized; not your decision
- Mercari: Split testing shows free shipping increases conversion by 10-15%
- FB Marketplace: Local pickup = no shipping = often higher prices
How often should I adjust prices on stale inventory?
Every 14-21 days is reasonable for most items. Don’t adjust daily—give the market time to respond. Set calendar reminders to review your listings systematically.
Is it better to price higher and accept offers or price at my minimum?
For most platforms, build in negotiation room. Buyers feel like they “won” something when you accept an offer. Price 15-20% above your true minimum on platforms with offer culture (Poshmark, FB Marketplace, eBay).
How do I handle price matching requests?
“I saw this cheaper on [another site]”—this is usually a negotiation tactic. Politely decline or offer a small discount if you want the sale. Never feel obligated to match prices that may not even be real.
Should I price differently for local pickup vs. shipped?
Yes. Local pickup items can often be priced 10-15% higher because:
- Buyer doesn’t pay shipping
- Buyer can inspect before paying
- Instant gratification
How do seasonal changes affect pricing?
Significantly. Holiday-themed items are worth 3-5x more in-season. Winter coats sell for 50%+ more September-February. Plan your listing timing and adjust prices seasonally.
What’s the best way to price a large lot or bundle?
Research individual item values first, then discount 15-25% for the bundle. The buyer gets a deal; you move multiple items in one transaction. Both win.
Related Tools
Put these free pricing tools to work:
- eBay Sold Link Generator - Instant access to sold comps while sourcing
- Platform Fee Calculator - See your actual profit after fees on any platform
- ROI Calculator - Know your return on investment before you buy
- Break-Even Calculator - Find your pricing floor for any item
Conclusion: Price with Confidence
Pricing doesn’t have to be a guessing game. With proper research, strategic positioning, and awareness of platform-specific dynamics, you can price every item with confidence.
The formula:
- Research sold comps (not asking prices)
- Choose your strategy (market, competitive, or premium)
- Adjust for platform
- Apply pricing psychology where appropriate
- Monitor and adjust systematically
Stop leaving money on the table. Stop watching inventory sit for months. Start pricing based on data, and watch your reselling business become predictably profitable.
Ready to stop guessing and start pricing with data?
Underpriced analyzes any item instantly—take a screenshot, get market comps, and know exactly what something is worth before you buy or list it. Try it free.
Further reading: